What a TikTok ban would look like for users

Trending 1 month ago

A U.S. authorities prohibition of TikTok could push users to fig retired replacement ways to entree nan app, thing that has go much communal successful different parts of nan world arsenic governments person instituted varying rules connected tech companies.

On Wednesday, nan House passed the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act, which would magnitude to a prohibition connected TikTok unless TikTok’s genitor institution sells nan app. The measure still needs to clear nan Senate, but President Joe Biden said past week that he would motion it if it comes to his desk.

If passed as written, nan measure would springiness nan president nan powerfulness to unit definite foreign-owned societal media apps to take betwixt trading them disconnected aliases being banned if U.S. intelligence agencies deem them a threat.

The bill’s astir vocal proponents and nationalist information officials person said this would use to TikTok’s genitor company, China-based Bytedance, for 2 reasons: nan app collects information connected its 170 cardinal American users, and successful mentation it could beryllium utilized to push Chinese propaganda.

Privacy advocates person agelong said that TikTok doesn’t cod substantially much information connected its users than different apps, and a amended solution would beryllium to simply walk a important information privateness law, which nan U.S. does not have. And while China is often accused of trying to seed online propaganda aimed astatine swaying American opinion, it is usually strikingly ineffective astatine it.

If nan measure passed and Biden were to usage its authorities to compel Bytedance to waste TikTok, nan institution would person 180 days to find a buyer. That would beryllium enormously frantic, said Kate Ruane, head of nan Free Expression Project astatine nan Center for Democracy and Technology, a Washington-based tech argumentation deliberation vessel that opposes nan bill. 

“There aren’t really that galore entities successful this world pinch nan benignant of money that it would return to beryllium capable to acquisition thing arsenic costly arsenic TikTok apt is,” Ruane said.

“And successful a woody that’s big, it would astir apt request to acquisition — and I deliberation that we would apt want it to acquisition — antitrust reappraisal successful nan United States. And antitrust merger review, particularly successful large analyzable deals, tin return a agelong time. Likely longer than six months,” she said.

It’s besides unclear that Bytedance has immoderate liking successful trading TikTok, sloppy of nan U.S. Congress. Bytedance didn’t respond to an email requesting comment. Sarah Kreps, nan head of Cornell University’s Tech Policy Institute, said she was skeptical Bytedance would sell.

“China’s not successful a awesome spot economically, but this is thing they’ve done that is very visibly successful astir nan world. So I don’t spot why they would waste it off,” Kreps said.

If a waste didn’t happen, it could group disconnected an unprecedented business successful American history: A celebrated smartphone app utilized by half nan country’s organization would abruptly go banned.

Under nan connection of nan bill, app stores would beryllium forbidden from hosting immoderate banned app. That would mostly use to Google, which maintains nan Play Store for Android users; and Apple, which hosts nan App Store. Neither institution responded to a petition for comment, but some historically comply pinch U.S. law.

In that case, nan TikTok app would nary longer beryllium easy accessible for astir Americans, and easiness of usage is simply a immense portion of nan app’s appeal. But it besides would apt thrust galore TikTok fans to find workarounds, said Cooper Quintin, nan elder unit technologist astatine nan Electronic Frontier Foundation, a nonprofit that promotes civilian liberties successful narration to technology. 

“I deliberation you’ll spot a batch of kids learning really to circumvent nan restrictions connected their phones, Quintin said.

“They’re surely not going to extremity group from utilizing TikTok by banning it. Yeah, you’ll astir apt trim down connected nan number of group utilizing it, but that conscionable makes it much exciting,” he said. “They’re gonna create a full caller procreation of hackers.”

TikTok users successful India, for instance, which banned TikTok successful 2020, often station videos showing ways to circumvent nan ban, though it isn’t clear that they each ever work.

It besides isn’t afloat clear really nan app shop prohibition would work. Both Google and Apple require users to person accounts pinch their services to usage their app stores, and those accounts person respective imaginable ways of identifying nan user’s location. 

While app stores whitethorn mostly categorize a personification by country, some companies let users to alteration what state they’re in. And it’s imaginable to make a 2nd relationship while visiting different state successful bid to look to beryllium resident location and download its apps. 

Laurin Weissinger, a visiting clever clever astatine nan Department of Computer Science astatine Tufts University, told NBC News that he often does this while walking successful Europe. 

“During Covid, I went to Europe, flying into Frankfurt. Germany astatine nan clip had an app to show vaccination status,” he said. “The app was not disposable successful nan U.S. App Store. So I had to make different relationship and get nan app."

It’s besides imaginable to load apps straight onto a telephone without going done a store, though it’s importantly harder to do truthful connected iPhones than connected Android phones. That whitethorn lead to much TikTok obsessives trying to load nan programme straight onto their telephone — aliases to accidentally downloading a malicious hacker’s version, Quintin said.

“My interest is what’ll dispersed is links to backdoored versions of TikTok that are malicious, that are really malware,” he said.

Kevin Collier

Kevin Collier is simply a newsman covering cybersecurity, privateness and exertion argumentation for NBC News.