How hospitals are fighting to keep their former doctors from seeing patients

Trending 1 month ago

David Lankford, an Indiana pediatrician who specializes successful treating critically sick children, says he decided to time off his occupation astatine Lutheran Hospital successful Fort Wayne aft it laid disconnected a group of pediatricians, causing nan number of patients he was seeing to summation much than fourfold.

But erstwhile Lankford took a occupation past twelvemonth astatine adjacent Parkview Health, his caller employer was threatened pinch a suit by his erstwhile employer, who alleged he had violated a noncompete clause successful his contract, according to tribunal records. Now, he’s months into a ineligible conflict complete whether he tin proceed taking attraction of patients successful Fort Wayne.

“There is simply a shortage of physicians who do nan subspecialty activity that I do successful Fort Wayne,” said Lankford successful a written consequence to questions. “I judge galore critically sick children and their families would person to recreation important distances astatine important hardship to get entree to care.”

Lankford is among a fistful of doctors who are fighting backmost successful tribunal against nan expanding prevalence of noncompete agreements, which often forestall a expert from seeing patients for 1 to 2 years wrong a geographic region if they are fired aliases discontinue their job. While employers opportunity nan agreements are basal to protect nan finance they make successful recruiting, trading and supporting their doctors, physicians reason nan provisions tin harm patients by restricting entree to attraction and consequence discouraging doctors from speaking retired astir unsafe aliases unethical conditions.

“We person seen these noncompetes summation exponentially complete nan past respective years, and it really goes against nan very ethos of medicine,” said Omar Atiq, president of nan American College of Physicians. “It takes awhile for physicians to commencement really knowing their patient, not conscionable nan illness for which they travel but nan diligent themselves, and to conscionable sever that narration is simply a large blow.”

Once viewed arsenic a regularisation reserved for high-level executives aliases workers pinch entree to waste and acquisition secrets, noncompete agreements person go pervasive crossed a scope of industries, from wellness attraction to accelerated nutrient chains, limiting nan employment opportunities of much than 30 cardinal workers, according to nan Federal Trade Commission. President Joe Biden pledged successful his State of nan Union reside successful 2023 to prohibition noncompetes crossed nan economy, and nan FTC is connected way to make a last determination astir a projected prohibition early this year, said a Biden management official.

Among doctors, nan agreements person go modular believe successful galore areas, pinch one survey by researchers astatine Ohio State University uncovering astir half of superior attraction physicians successful group practices and much than a 3rd of physicians employed astatine hospitals aliases free-standing clinics were bound by a noncompete agreement. The prevalence of noncompete agreements has accrued arsenic much doctors are now employed by hospitals aliases ample wellness systems, which person been steadily buying up group aesculapian practices, said Atiq. For patients, nan believe tin consequence successful an abrupt disruption of attraction pinch nary mentation of wherever their expert has gone aliases why, said Atiq. Doctors often person nonsolicitation clauses tied into nan noncompete agreements, preventing them from letting patients cognize wherever they are relocating to.

The American Hospital Association, which represents nan country’s for-profit hospitals, has opposed nan projected prohibition by nan Biden administration. Chad Golder, wide counsel for nan AHA, said its members chiefly usage noncompete agreements for their doctors and elder executives, not lower-skilled workers who person little bargaining powerfulness erstwhile negotiating an employment agreement, and that nan restrictions are needed, successful part, to protect nan financial finance hospitals make successful recruiting, relocating, trading and training their doctors.

“We deliberation they are important for protecting investments that hospitals make to enlistee doctors and elder executives,” said Golder. “Imagine you’re a agrarian infirmary retired successful nan state and you walk a batch of money to bring connected a caller physician, to get them integrated into nan community, to train them, and they time off aft a short play of clip aft you’ve made each this finance to get them retired there.”

Golder said that deterring doctors from leaving their employer tin besides use patients by maintaining continuity of attraction crossed a azygous wellness system. When doctors alteration jobs it tin require patients to person to transportation their aesculapian records and successful immoderate instances person to coordinate attraction betwixt doctors astatine aggregate hospitals, he said.

But critics, including 2 of nan largest expert groups — the American Medical Association and nan American College of Physicians — say nan agreements tin lend to expert shortages, sever doctor-patient relationships, and deter doctors from speaking retired for fearfulness of being fired and incapable to activity elsewhere successful nan community.

‘It’s really bleak here’

In Savannah, Georgia, HCA Healthcare-owned Memorial Health University Medical Center threatened 1 of its erstwhile OB-GYNs pinch a suit past twelvemonth erstwhile nan expert went to activity astatine a adjacent session focused connected treating low-income women, according to a missive nan expert shared pinch NBC News. Several months prior, nan expert had their statement terminated without origin by Memorial, but nan noncompete remained successful place.

Under nan doctor’s noncompete agreement, they were incapable to activity arsenic an OB-GYN wrong a 25-mile radius of Memorial for 1 twelvemonth pursuing nan extremity of their contract.

The expert has since near their occupation astatine nan clinic, wherever they were treating mostly uninsured women, and is readying a move retired of nan area. The expert asked that their sanction not beryllium published for fearfulness it could harm their early occupation prospects.

Memorial said successful a connection that noncompete agreements thief protect nan important costs nan infirmary makes successful recruiting a physician, paying for moving costs, and different expenses that travel pinch mounting up a physician’s practice, for illustration hiring unit and leasing space. The infirmary said its noncompete agreements don’t forestall physicians from mounting up a backstage practice.

In Georgia, noncompete agreements person been contributing to a shortage of OB-GYNs crossed nan state, wherever immoderate women person to hold months to get regular care, said Kate Boyenga, executive head of nan Georgia Obstetrics and Gynecology Society. She said her statement has begun looking into whether location is immoderate authorities legislative action that could limit nan scope of noncompete agreements for OB-GYNs to thief reside nan shortages.

“When women don’t person entree to that care, erstwhile it is exacerbated by having to recreation acold distances, having to return disconnected activity to spell to prenatal appointments, having to unafraid kid attraction and having to person capable transportation, they’re not going to get nan attraction arsenic overmuch arsenic they should, and that’s what’s going to lead to complications,” said Boyenga.

Jessica Swanson is 1 of those patients who has struggled to get OB-GYN attraction successful Savannah moreover though she has backstage security and has worked for much than a decade arsenic a reproductive wellness pedagogue and is simply a trained commencement doula.

When Swanson was astir 4 months pregnant pinch her 2nd kid successful 2022, she began looking to move to different OB-GYN successful Savannah aft seeing galore “red flags” pinch her existent doctor, she said. But aft calling each OB-GYN believe successful nan area, she was either told they weren’t taking caller patients aliases they didn’t return her calls.

When she began having complications later during her pregnancy, she had to show up astatine nan emergency room, wherever nan expert connected telephone performed a cesarean section.

“I should person had a prime successful my provider. It was an incredibly frustrating experience,” said Swanson. “I conscionable deliberation astir really overmuch I brought into that business — my level of education, my connections, my expertise to navigate wellness care, really bully security — and I still could not navigate myself to capable wellness care.”

Even aft giving birth, she still wasn’t capable to find an OB-GYN to dainty her erstwhile she developed mastitis, a achy inflammation of nan bosom insubstantial caused by breastfeeding, and alternatively had to spell to an urgent attraction clinic.

“It was conscionable a really bad acquisition overall, and I consciousness really fto down by nan larger aesculapian organization here,” Swanson said. “It’s really bleak here.”

Two cardiologists from different HCA-owned wellness system, Mission Health Community successful North Carolina, said they were besides threatened pinch ineligible action complete a noncompete clause successful their statement erstwhile they near to activity for Pardee Hospital. The doctors, Marian Taylor and Lillia LaPlace, sued Mission to person nan noncompete agreements thrown out. The lawsuit was dismissed successful March, and Taylor and LaPlace are presently moving for Pardee. A lawyer for Taylor and LaPlace declined to remark connected nan case, and nan doctors didn’t respond to a petition for comment. Mission Health besides didn’t respond to a petition for comment.

In Indiana, Lankford had signed a noncompete statement erstwhile he started moving astatine Lutheran Hospital successful 2018 arsenic a pediatric captious attraction intensivist. Under nan agreement, he was prohibited from practicing immoderate shape of medicine wrong 30 miles of Lutheran for 1 twelvemonth pursuing his past time of employment there. When Lankford signed nan noncompete agreement, he said he thought astir nan implications it could have, but didn’t deliberation he had an action to discuss complete nan provision.

“I had thought astir it, but had experiences which led maine to deliberation that nan hospitals which could employment maine were not willing successful negotiating noncompetes aliases employment contracts individually,” he said.

Lankford’s lawyers person based on that nan statement should beryllium invalidated because Lutheran changed nan position of Lankford’s statement erstwhile successful 2022 it fired a group of pediatricians astatine nan hospital, leaving Lankford and his remaining workfellow responsible for seeing each pediatric patients crossed nan hospital, not conscionable those successful nan intensive attraction portion wherever he was assigned. The move importantly accrued his workload without further compensation, according to tribunal records.

“I felt that my erstwhile employer breached my contract. I judge I gave them galore opportunities to hole nan problem complete a span of respective months,” said Lankford. “In my opinion, they did thing to hole nan problem. I felt that if they weren’t going to grant my contract, I shouldn’t beryllium bound by nan noncompete successful nan statement that they refused to honor.”

Lutheran said successful tribunal filings that it did require Lankford to statesman seeing wide pediatric patients passim nan hospital, not conscionable successful nan intensive attraction unit. But it denied that nan alteration successful Lankford’s occupation duties was a breach of statement and based on that his caller duties were wrong nan scope of his training and employment agreement. In a countersuit revenge against Lankford and Parkview by Lutheran, nan infirmary alleges that it was Lankford who had breached his statement by leaving his position and violating nan noncompete agreement. Lutheran says it offered Lankford nan opportunity to bargain retired nan noncompete proviso for an undisclosed amount.

Lutheran alleges that arsenic a consequence of Lankford’s actions, it has suffered a nonaccomplishment of business and goodwill successful nan organization on pinch costs associated pinch recruiting Lankford and having to switch him. It is seeking compensatory and punitive damages on pinch attorney’s fees and different related costs.

A spokesperson for Lutheran declined to comment.

In August, Lankford won a preliminary injunction making nan noncompete statement unenforceable and allowing him to spot patients astatine Parkview, astatine slightest temporarily. But nan injunction is only preliminary and nan ineligible conflict could agelong connected for months longer, moreover beyond erstwhile Lankford’s noncompete statement expires, said Kathleen DeLaney, a lawyer for Lankford who has represented galore doctors bound by noncompete agreements.

For Lankford, he says he felt he had nary different action but to return his lawsuit to tribunal aft he was incapable to support moving astatine his caller employer.

“It was very difficult to person to extremity working, to person fits and starts pinch a caller job, and to beryllium distracted from my master profession by nan ineligible dispute. But I cognize that it was nan correct point to do for my patients, my organization and my family,” said Lankford.

Battle complete pain patients

In Ohio, Anjay Khandelwal, a surgeon, had to return his lawsuit each nan measurement to nan state’s Supreme Court earlier winning nan correct to dainty pediatric pain patients astatine Akron Children’s Hospital aft being sued by his erstwhile employer.

Khandelwal started moving astatine MetroHealth successful Cleveland successful 2013 and signed a noncompete statement restricting him from providing akin aesculapian aliases master services wrong a 35-mile radius for 2 years pursuing his past time of activity astatine MetroHealth, according to ineligible filings.

But successful 2020, Khandelwal resigned from his occupation and accepted a position arsenic nan head of nan pain halfway astatine Akron Children’s Hospital, nan only different pain halfway successful nan noncompete radius. After learning astir his caller position, MetroHealth sued Khandelwal and Akron Children’s, arguing successful tribunal filings that it had invested importantly successful hiring and recruiting Khandelwal and processing his connections and visibility successful nan region. It besides based on Khandelwal had entree to confidential waste and acquisition secrets, for illustration pricing information and strategical plans.

Khandelwal denied nan allegation successful tribunal and based on that patients’ entree to pain attraction successful nan region could beryllium jeopardized if he wasn’t capable to believe room for 2 years.

The tribunal ruled partially successful favour of Khandelwal, saying he could statesman moving arsenic a pain surgeon astatine Akron Children’s, but wasn’t capable to commencement moving arsenic nan center’s head for a twelvemonth aft leaving MetroHealth. The ruling was upheld by nan Ohio Supreme Court successful 2022 and Khandelwal is now moving arsenic nan head of nan pain institute astatine Akron Children’s Hospital.

Khandelwal and Akron Children’s didn’t respond to requests for comment. MetroHealth declined to comment.

Despite immoderate victories for physicians, it is still comparatively uncommon for doctors to situation their noncompete agreements successful tribunal because of nan financial and reputational consequences, said Atiq. Instead, doctors often softly move to a caller metropolis if they want to time off their occupation aliases are fired, uprooting their families and leaving their patients behind, but avoiding nan consequence of a lawsuit.

“Why would a personification who is successful their 30s pinch 1 aliases 2 mini children, being nan main breadwinner for nan family, jeopardize that? What’s easier for that personification is to conscionable time off and spell location else,” said Atiq. “Inherently, it is wrong.”

Shannon Pettypiece

Shannon Pettypiece is elder argumentation newsman for NBC News digital.